Is Medication Assisted Treatment Just Trading One Addiction for Another?
No. Medication assisted treatment is not trading one addiction for another, even though it’s the worry people bring to CMAR more than any other. Addiction is compulsive use that keeps causing harm.
MAT uses an FDA-approved medication at a steady, prescribed dose to calm cravings and withdrawal, so a person can function and do the work of recovery. At CMAR, the medication is always one part of a plan that includes therapy.
Key takeaways
- MAT is not trading one addiction for another. Addiction is compulsive use despite harm; MAT is a steady, prescribed dose.
- Physical dependence on a prescribed medication is not the same thing as addiction.
- Each MAT medication does a specific job, from easing withdrawal to blocking a drug’s effects.
- At CMAR, medication always comes with therapy, groups and case management.
James is a Certified Addiction Specialist who has worked in addiction treatment in Colorado since 2015. We asked him the question patients bring to their first visit.
Where the Fear of Trading One Addiction for Another Comes From
Most people who ask have a reason. Maybe you spent years watching someone you love chase the next pill or the next drink. So when a doctor says “a medication every day,” your stomach drops. A film each morning? A shot each month? It can sound like a new habit with a prescription.
James starts with the brain. During substance use, he says, “there are so many things happening in the brain and so many changes that are created.”
Medication is there to settle those changes down. It isn’t there to restart the cycle that caused them:
- Addiction: use you can’t control, that keeps causing problems and takes over more of your life.
- MAT: a prescribed dose, taken the same way every time and managed by a medical provider, so the rest of your life can come back.
Dependence vs. Addiction: Why They Aren't the Same
Dependence and addiction are different things, and someone taking MAT as prescribed can have the first without the second. Mixing them up is what makes MAT sound like a swap, so it helps to see how clinicians define each one:
Physical dependence is the body getting used to a medication. Stop it suddenly and withdrawal follows. It happens with plenty of medicines taken exactly as prescribed, including pain medication after surgery.
Addiction, diagnosed today as a substance use disorder, is a pattern of use that causes real impairment or distress, with loss of control at its center.
Researchers from the National Institute on Drug Abuse note that people often confuse the two, and that the difference matters when choosing treatment (Journal of Clinical Investigation, 2020). The same logic answers whether buprenorphine creates a psychological dependency when it’s taken as prescribed.
What MAT Medication Actually Does
Think of MAT medication as taking the body off emergency mode. One medication eases withdrawal, another quiets cravings, another blocks a drug’s effects. Once that settles, a person can actually show up for therapy, for groups and for the rest of recovery. In James’s words:
Post-acute withdrawal is the stretch after detox when cravings, poor sleep, low mood and irritability can linger for weeks or longer (SAMHSA, Protracted Withdrawal, 2010). It’s one of the main reasons people return to a substance after deciding to stop.
Each medication CMAR uses does a different job:
| Medication | Used for | What it does |
|---|---|---|
| Suboxone, Subutex, Sublocade (buprenorphine) | Opioid use disorder | Eases withdrawal and cravings; its effects level off at moderate doses |
| Vivitrol (naltrexone) | Alcohol and opioid use disorder | Blocks the effects of opioids and lowers alcohol cravings |
| Antabuse (disulfiram) | Alcohol use disorder | Makes drinking cause an unpleasant reaction |
Mechanisms are summarized from SAMHSA TIP 63, the Vivitrol prescribing information and the disulfiram label on DailyMed. A CMAR medical provider decides which one fits, as part of how MAT works at CMAR.
The Medication Is One Piece of the Puzzle
At CMAR, medication is never the whole treatment. It handles cravings and withdrawal so they stop running the day. The deeper work happens in therapy, where people deal with stress, old patterns and the habits that grew up around using. James puts it simply:
That’s how CMAR is built. Medication comes alongside individual therapy, group work, DBT and case management in our PHP Program and 3-Day IOP.
Worried that MAT will only swap one problem for another? Ask us on your first call. It’s the question we hear most, and the answer becomes part of your plan. See how getting started at CMAR works.
What Changes Once Cravings and Withdrawal Are Under Control
When cravings and withdrawal ease up, people get their attention back. Mornings stop being about the next craving, and suddenly there’s room for therapy and for the rest of life. Of everything that changes, James points to one shift above the rest:
The most rewarding change, he says, is watching a patient learn, sometimes for the first time in their life, “what it looks like to develop self-love and a positive self-regard.”
The changes he sees most often:
- More stability in day-to-day life
- Fewer cravings pulling at attention
- Room to take part in life again
Medication Assisted Treatment in Denver at CMAR
If the fear of trading one addiction for another has kept you from calling, it isn’t a reason to wait. CMAR treats alcohol and opioid use disorder through MAT for alcohol in Denver and MAT for opioids, with comfort medications and medication for alcohol withdrawal when detox comes first.
Your first visit covers your history, your goals and which medication, if any, fits, and our team can verify your insurance benefits before you come in.
That fear is part of a wider stigma around MAT that keeps people from care that works. If you want to stop drinking, the next question is usually Vivitrol vs Antabuse. Learn more about medication assisted treatment in Denver, or call CMAR in Denver at (833) 448-0127.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Suboxone just replacing one drug with another?
No. Suboxone’s main ingredient, buprenorphine, is taken at one steady dose, and past a moderate dose its effects stop climbing. It eases withdrawal and cravings so you can get on with your day, and the naloxone in it discourages misuse. Your body may grow dependent on it. Taken as prescribed, that’s treatment, not addiction.
Is someone on MAT considered sober?
SAMHSA defines recovery as a process of change in which people improve their health and wellness, live self-directed lives and work toward their full potential (SAMHSA). Taking a prescribed medication as directed fits within that. The medication isn’t used to get high; it’s used to stay stable while life moves forward.
Do you have to stay on MAT forever?
There’s no set end date. Some people take an MAT medication for months, others for years, and the right length depends on your health, your progress and your goals. What matters is that any change is planned. Never stop a medication on your own; your CMAR provider adjusts or tapers it with you.
Is Vivitrol addictive?
No. Vivitrol contains naltrexone, an opioid blocker, and its label notes it isn’t associated with developing tolerance or dependence. It’s given as an injection by a healthcare provider about once a month to reduce drinking or prevent a return to opioids. Because it blocks opioids, your provider will talk with you about pain medication.
Who is a good candidate for medication assisted treatment?
Most people with alcohol or opioid use disorder who have struggled to get time away from the substance are good candidates, James says. CMAR also uses comfort medications that help with withdrawal from virtually any substance. A CMAR medical provider reviews your history and health before recommending any medication.
Related posts

